Let’s Talk! Health Care For All
Hosted by Miri Newman and Elianna. Featuring River Shoal and Colin Stackhouse. Produced by the Let's Talk! Podcast Collective. Audio and transcript editing by Hannah "Asher" Sham. Web hosting by Eugene Holden.
Let’s Talk! Health Care For All
Summary: In this episode of Let’s Talk!, 51ÁÔÆæÈë¿Ú’s student podcast on disability culture, hosts Elianna and Miri explore how the U.S. healthcare system fails disabled people, from forced-poverty benefit limits to the debate over medically assisted death. They talk with River Shoal and Colin Stackhouse of Health Care For All Oregon about the push to make Oregon the first state with universal healthcare, and how listeners can help.
- Hosted By: Miri Newman and Elianna
- Featuring: River Shoal and Colin Stackhouse
- Produced By: Let’s Talk! Podcast Collective
- Audio and Transcript Editing: Hannah “Asher” Sham
- Web Hosting: Eugene Holden
- Released on: 11/20/2026
- More resources at our home website.
Episode Transcript
Transcript edited by Hannah “Asher” Sham
Intro
Kylo: You’re listening to Let’s Talk!. Let’s Talk! is a digital space for students 51ÁÔÆæÈë¿Ú experiencing disabilities to share their perspectives, ideas, and worldviews in an inclusive and accessible environment. The views and opinions expressed in this program are those of the speakers, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions or positions of 51ÁÔÆæÈë¿Ú, PCC Foundation, or our community partners. We broadcast on our home website, , on Spotify, on , and .
Medically Assisted Death & Disability
Elianna: Last month, the UK Parliament held a vote on whether to include medically assisted death to their health service coverage. This had been introduced in October twenty twenty-four with a goal of giving the terminally ill the freedom to choose to end their life early in a legal and pain-free way. This has been advocated for, for centuries, including advocates like the author of The Yellow Wallpaper, Charlotte Perkins Gilman, who ended her own life in nineteen thirty-five after being diagnosed with incurable breast cancer in nineteen thirty-two. The goal of medically assisted death is to prevent unnecessary pain and suffering, which can be a part of the final unknown. Which can be a part of the dying process. It also grants the person more agency while facing the final unknown. My public health professor at PSU noted many people who get the medication for medically assisted death frequently don’t take them before passing naturally, but find comfort in knowing they can choose to end in a peaceful way on their terms. Oregon is one of fourteen states to have a Death with Dignity act, with our state’s law being enacted in nineteen ninety-seven. The requirements are for the person to be at least eighteen years old, mentally well enough to make their own healthcare decisions, and have been diagnosed with a condition likely to end their life within a six-month time period. There are some who would like these requirements to allow them to end their life earlier, like for someone I interviewed for my thesis research. The person I interviewed is an elder who is dealing with mental decline and would like to be able to not experience the suffering of losing their mental faculties. They do not have the means to hire a nurse for aid or live at an assisted facility. This leads to the problem some disability advocates have with medically assisted death, the potential for eugenics and the unfair use by the poor if money can help them live. This leads to the problem some disability advocates have with medically assisted death. The potential for eugenics and the unfair use by the poor if money can help them live. Health insurance, whether single payer through the government or private, requires money to pay for labor, supplies, facilities, research, and so on. This has led to those who need more help, like the disabled, the elderly, and the poor, losing their coverage and services. This is most infamously notable in Canada, where the nation’s MAID, medically assistance in dying, has been sent to disabled people asking for mobility equipment. Paralympian Christine Gauthier asked for a stair lift to be added to her home to help her access her own house. In response, the government employee sent her a MAID pamphlet. In her testimony to the Canadian government, she said, “I have a letter saying that, ‘If you’re so desperate, madam, we can offer you MAID, medical assistance in dying.'”. Another Canadian wheelchair user was sent a MAID pamphlet when he asked for repairs to his wheelchair. There have been other concerns about people who choose MAID over suffering through not getting their needs met due to lack of funds. Jacobin Magazine notes of a man who chose MAID due to not having access to a mattress which wouldn’t give him bedsores. The Tyee, a Canadian news site, notes a woman who was a woman who struggled with long-term suicidality issues was offered MAID at a mental health crisis center due to how overwhelmed the system is. Another woman sought MAID after not being able to find housing which wouldn’t set off her respiratory sensitivities. Multiple reports on this issue show a desire for those who seek MAID don’t wanna be a burden on their loved ones, but these burdens have more to do with the lack of funding and resources than any actual facing of the end of perpetual suffering. With this in mind, disabled people and advocates in the UK fought against the medically assisted death legislation and succeeded. This has led to discourse around autonomy and the right to not suffer for the people who do, and the right for disabled people to exist without being told they’re too much of a burden and should kill themselvesÂ
Why the US Has No Universal Healthcare
Elianna: Oregon is looking to be the first state to instate universal healthcare through Healthcare For All Oregon. As most Americans know and agree on, private healthcare is too expensive. Disabled people who do get on disability, which can be an extensively drawn-out and torturous endeavor, are then capped at only being allowed two thousand dollars in total assets if single or three thousand dollars if married. This cap, set in nineteen eighty-nine, now enforces poverty conditions on the disabled, including preventing them from getting married as they stand to lose assistance when the shared assets from marriage go above three thousand dollars. This is called forced poverty by those who work in disability rights. Even a twenty dollar surplus can lead to people getting booted from their benefits. New Medicare rules doled out by the Trump administration are putting disabled people in more of a healthcare bind as they demand more work and income than a disabled person not on benefits can usually achieve. Many Americans are unaware the reason behind the US’s lack of a single-payer plan, which is present in most other countries in the world. The reasoning for this is eugenics, racism, and greed. This is a heavily summarized account of a reading which will be provided for this, with this episode The first nation to get universal healthcare was what is now called Germany back in 1883. The Industrial Revolution led to populations concentrating in cities to work. The workers were exploited, the workers then unionized and demanded better treatment, which included healthcare. In the States, there was a very important man named Frederick Ludwig Hoffman. Friedrich Ludwig Hoffman. He later renamed himself to Frederick Hoffman for reasons which we, which will be explained. Growing up sickly and economically struggling, he emigrated to the US from Germany in 1884 with only $4.87 in his pocket, no degree, and unable to speak English. He was determined to prove himself after being rejected from military service and his mother, who called him a good for nothing. Hoffman became a statistician who specialized in health and demographics for the Prudential Insurance Company of America in 1891. Having written on the importance of safe workplaces, the reports he wrote being as foundational and influential as they still are, what he was about to do made everything so much worse. For whatever reason, Hoffman was a scientific racist who didn’t put two and two together on the outcomes of Black Americans being due to the same socioeconomic disparities he wrote about in his studies on white industrial workers. A proponent of eugenics and a hater of all things German, he rallied against efforts being made at the time for the US to develop their own universal healthcare system, as it would, in his opinion, inhumanely keep Black communities alive, which were destined to die out, and it was German, and it would impin- infringe on the business interest of the company he worked for. It wasn’t scientific racism alone which killed this turn-of-the-century healthcare endeavor. Libertarianism funded by plutocrats was and continues to be a significant contributor. Business interests, specifically insurance interests, did not want to be on the hook or compete with government insurance, which would meet the workers’ unions demands. So, they bribed and funded publicity campaigns with Hoffman’s, an insurance man, help and guidance. The long short of it was Hoffman, with the insurance companies, spread cherry-picked and misleading information about other nations’ single-payer healthcare systems while arguing government-paid healthcare would reduce the freedom of the American worker, even control them in various ways. This is nothing new to anyone following the arguments from when the Affordable Care Act, derided as Obamacare, was rolled out, or when government support programs are discussed. What we know now is private healthcare bankrupts people, prevents them from getting the care they need, and overcomplicates the practice and acquisition of medicine. US international companies cannot compete as well with, as other nations’ companies due to how much money they need to put into private healthcare plan, into a private healthcare plan for their workers. Companies could, would pay less in taxes covering healthcare than what they do now in private plans. One group is endeavoring to bring universal healthcare to the US, starting in our very own state of Oregon, Healthcare For All Oregon, AKA HCAO. Today we are interviewing HCAO about their– what their plan means for the disabled. Today we are interviewing HCAO about what their plan means for the disabled.
Meet Health Care For All Oregon
Miri: Thank you River and Colin for joining us today. Would you like to take a brief moment and introduce yourselves before we get into the meat of the questions?
River: Yeah. Hi, I’m River Shoal, and I am one of the co-founders of the Accessibility Alliance, part of , and generally speaking, a disabled activist. I’ll bounce to Colin.Ìý
Collin: Yeah. Thanks Miri, and thanks Elianna. I’m Colin Stackhouse and I’m one of the few staff members with Health Care For All Oregon. I do a lot of things, but focus on our social media and other kinds of communications for the statewide organization.Ìý
Miri: Fantastic.
Elianna: Thank you guys so much for having us. This is been really exciting.Ìý
Miri: And thank you guys for taking time out of your days to come and talk to us. So, we’ll start things off by asking, for those who are unfamiliar with the goal of Health Care For All Oregon, how would you describe your mission, and what is the benefit of single-payer healthcare?Â
Collin: So, I’ll read the mission statement for Healthcare For All Oregon, which is on our website, hcao.org. HCAO educates about and advocates for an equitable, affordable, comprehensive, high quality, publicly funded, universal healthcare system which we see will improve the lives of individuals, families, and communities across Oregon and throughout the United States. “” is one of several approaches that exist around the world to achieve the sort of baseline policy goal of Universal Coverage or Universal Healthcare. The best performing countries that have Healthcare Systems around the world, like Taiwan specifically; Taiwan has a Single Payer System as well as some of the other countries that maybe as Americans we’re more familiar with. Even though there are challenges with every single Universal Healthcare System, challenges with any healthcare system as we see. But, Canada and the United Kingdom are also examples of a Single Payer Universal Healthcare System. They work to lower the costs. Around the world, we can see that it lowers costs to have a single payer system and one of the best examples of that is; that instead of negotiating for different rates or prescription drug prices, as smaller groups of people that have different insurance plans, like negotiating on behalf of Blue Cross Blue Shield, or negotiating on just the tiny Medicaid population, in the state of Oregon, a whole community, a whole population. Everybody is negotiating together and so can get better prices and lower drug prescription costs.
River: Yep. And a really simple way to look at what we advocate for is in the phrase everybody in, nobody out. That is what we are looking for when it comes to universal healthcare, and it’s to use that collective power of everybody being in one group to be able to bring appropriate levels of care here, in rural areas, as well as bring down prices. Because, we’ve got that collective bargaining power that way.
Elianna: It’s like in our class about Universal Healthcare or the History of Insurance in the US; one thing that was brought up to us was because the US is a private healthcare industry, we can’t compete on an international market in the same way the other countries can. Because, they’re so busy having to put money into employee benefits plans that they can’t then put that money back into R&D or paying their employees better. It really is this thing where no one wins because there’s this middleman with the health insurance company.Ìý
River: Right. And every for-profit industry has one requirement: to make money for shareholders.Ìý
Miri: To profit, yeah.Ìý
River: Yeah. The healthcare industry’s ultimate goal is actually not to provide healthcare, it’s to provide benefit to shareholders, and if they can do that through ending lives, that is the choice they make. When you have a system that is not reliant on strictly for profit, then you can focus on actual outcomes and that’s one of the biggest differences I see when we look at pursuing universal healthcare is you shift the focus from how much money can we get to how much healthcare can we get. Because, those are not the same thing.
Miri: I think that’s really well said. Yeah, Elianna, go ahead and take the next one.Ìý
What the Plan Will Look Like
Elianna: What will HCAO look like when fully operational? What will the experience be like? Will ambulances be affordable? How will pay for EMS, nurses, doctors, technicians, and so on change? Will these groups have more agency in management of healthcare, or will there be a different management role? This is also something I think about. We have a coworker in AEDR– Accessible Education Disability Resources, our broader branch here 51ÁÔÆæÈë¿Ú– she’s in her internship right now on the coast as someone who provides healthcare through the ambulance and she’s already had to deal with people going, “I don’t know if I can afford this ambulance ride.”
River: Yeah. We see that a lot. We see people who choose to take a Lyft, who choose to take transit, who choose to just not get healthcare at all. A delay in diagnosis can mean death and yet, time after time, when you’re looking at a bill in the thousands to tens to hundreds of thousands for some of these medications, for any kind of cancer treatment, for any complex illnesses, your choice is death or death. Because you’re either gonna starve to death, or the illness is gonna kill you, and you have to decide, “Is my life worth enough? Who can I keep alive the longest in this?”. These aren’t decisions that we should have to be making. Because we know there’s the money to be able to do this. This isn’t some abstract thing. We can see the yachts. We know where the money is. It’s not exactly like they’re hiding it and when they are hiding it, fun fact, we also know where they’re hiding it and how. It’s not a mystery. It’s really not. When it comes to this, we know what’s wrong with the Oregon tax system. We know that if you’re educated, and I strongly recommend a podcast about this, Oregon Measures 5 and 50 that need to be adjusted and repealed so that people can be supported by a tax system that was designed to keep wealthy hoarding funds and screw the rest of us. So, we know where the issues are funding-wise, and we also know that it is possible to have a universal healthcare system that brings down costs for everybody so that families aren’t bearing this burden, so businesses aren’t bearing this burden. So, going back to your question; first off, Healthcare For Oregon is the nonprofit that’s advocating for the new system, and it’s not what the new universal health care system, that’ll likely have a different name. The current group associated with the work that’s coming up with all of this is actually the , or UHGB. So, on that, front, so they’re the ones working on it. I’ll let Colin go into the “when?” and, a little bit, on the “how?”, There.Ìý
Miri: Thank you.Ìý
Collin: Yeah. Yeah, sure. Thanks, River. So, like River said, Healthcare For All Oregon, HCAO, is the nonprofit that River and I are associated with. The current group is the Universal Health Plan Governance for the UHPGB, and you can see all of their work at, ““. The way that we’re all hoping and the way that the recommendation puts forward; the recommendation, by the way, is being delivered December 1st to our Oregon legislature. That recommendation, or the plan will be, featuring in the 2027 legislative session. So, we as an organization and us as a state need to pivot our attention. If you were thinking about the formation of the plan by the governance board, the intention now is to pivot our efforts to affecting the legislators’ creation of a bill based on the plan. So, in the 2027 session, our organization, and hopefully everyone around the state, will be influencing our legislators to not let this plan die and to actually give us an opportunity to vote on this issue, because we want the opportunity to decide for ourselves whether we as a state want universal healthcare.
River: Right. I’m gonna pause you right there. So, we’re filming this on Election Day.
Miri: Oh, yeah!
River: So, by the time this is all coming out-Â
Miri: Yeah…
River: The election will likely be-Â
Collin: This year’s gonna be our year!
River: Yeah. So, fingers crossed. As you’re going through and you’re celebrating your wins and you’re mourning your losses for the things that you were voting on, whatever the outcome may be; I wanna remind people while that celebration is absolutely essential, and something that liberals need to do more of is celebrate our wins, the next step is to continue to fight. Just because we got them elected doesn’t mean we sit on our haunches. Like this here, call your legislators and be like, “Not only do I support universal healthcare, but this is what I want in that universal health plan. This is what I want in there.” They have the ability to put that in there, so make your voices heard. Tell them that you want it and tell them what you want in it, because they can make it happen and don’t ever let a legislator tell you they can’t. This is literally their job. Their job is to make it happen and if they can’t, then maybe next time we vote them out and put somebody in who can, with all due respect.
Collin: We’re stoked. There’s so many things to talk about with this effort, and the next two years are gonna be really busy. So, maybe, Elianna and Miri we could come back in a couple months and check in. ‘Cause, there’ll be certainly updates 6, 12, and 18 months from now. So-Â
Miri: Oh, yeah.Ìý
Collin: To answer your question about what it will look like when it’s fully functional, what the experience will be like; ambulances, how will those cost. So, this effort that we advocate for and the work of the governance board and this eventual thing that we’re gonna vote on is to create a single-payer system or as close as we can get as one state to creating this, this single-payer system. Now, without getting into all the caveats, there’s no way to kick out insurance companies. So, there will be private insurance in the state of Oregon. It’s not legally possible to say they’re not allowed. But, it would de-incentivize and, both through just rational thought and also through legal mechanisms, likely they would not be able to offer the exact same coverage as this new statewide universal single-payer healthcare plan. But, private insurance could exist to offer supplemental things that are not covered, right? So, that’s a likely scenario in the future. There are some needs that the current plan is likely going to include for funding. Even though there’s the possibility that these waivers won’t happen; I believe that in the recommendation, we’ll see in December, will account for some of these alternatives, or accounting for this problem or this potential problem. But, to do the plan as is being developed, we will need some federal waivers. So, we’ll need flexibility as a state to have access to Medicare money and Medicaid money. There is two different waivers that we’ll need to accomplish this. One is called the , and the other is the . I can’t off the top of my head remember which one’s for Medicaid, which one’s for Medicare, but they both are necessary for us to have the flexibility as a state that we would need to have, from the patient’s point of view, a single-payer system. So, there’s talk about when those waivers expire or there’s an opportunity for states to get new waivers. Those timelines are around, are 2030 and 2032, so there’s a possibility that we as a state could vote to make this transition in 2028. There could be a partial implementation based on the waivers by 2030 potentially a full implementation with the second waiver by 2032, regardless of how it looks on the backend. So, maybe there’s, a wraparound final system where it’s too complicated to have total control of Medicare, for example. So, the backside of this new statewide insurance plan, this new public corporation; on the backend, there’s some admin people that need to parse out, “Oh, this money actually needs to be able, be billed to Medicare, and this money is actually technically part of the new Oregon insurance plan for everybody in the state, and that goes this way.” But, from the patient’s point of view, that shouldn’t matter. So this, a single-payer system means that at the point of care, there’s no further cost. So some systems do have co-pays and co-insurance, but we advocate for no co-pays, no co-insurance, that once you leave the hospital, you leave the emergency room, you leave your scheduled primary care visit; there’s no more surprise bills. There’s nothing. Because, you and the whole state has already paid for this care on the front end in the form of taxes. Or, slightly different; employer and employee taxes. In systems that are highly functional, like Taiwan I mentioned before has consistently been rated one of the, the best in the world. They have the single-payer system, so there’s their national health insurance program. But, most of the care, I guess, 90% of the care is done by these private companies. So, similar to our current non-profit hospitals, or private clinics, or whatever people in Taiwan are going where they want to go. There’s like basically no wait times, as like a side note, right? So, there’s hardly any wait times in this country that has a super high satisfaction rate. But, people are going to the private clinics that they wanna see, but the payment side of it is taken care of, and that is the single-payer national health insurance program. No further cost to payments at the point of care, no further cost to patients at their point of care, and that’s the kind of system that we’re working for in Oregon.
Interim Support & Costs of Care
Miri: So, I’m gonna hop ahead a couple questions real quick. Just ’cause it ties in directly with what you just said. According to the UHPGB site, projections do have it being largely implemented in 2032 currently. So, is there a plan for the interim of support for people who are unable to afford medical care and prescriptions for the time being? Is there a movement for providing that as well before the official changes come in the government?
River: So, what I’ll say to that is a, “no, but…”. That is not part of this particular plan. But, what I will say is that just having been around some of this advocacy, working with Health Care For All Oregon, and talking to some of the legislators; some of the legislators are talking about a gap plan. That plan is not tied into this plan, so I don’t have the details on that. I don’t know what steps are there. I know there are talks about it. So, what does that mean for people listening? Well, it goes back to the thing I said earlier where I said, “Hey, ring ’em up!”. Tell them this is what you need. Tell them that not only do you expect them to pass this universal health plan, but you expect them to find an interim solution as well. If they tell you, “you can’t”, then you’re gonna have to tell ’em, “Yeah, well then I can’t vote for you next time. I’ll vote for your opponent.” Because we’re the boss. We need to be telling them these things and we need to be not letting them slide. I have a lot of respect for legislators, I do. It’s a hard job. But I also think there has been a tendency to get very comfortable and be like, “Oh, this is hard… So, maybe? Eh, I don’t know if I wanna risk…” No. No, now is the time that you risk. Now is the time that you step up. I got the letter saying that I might lose my health insurance, that I need to go battle with the system to see if I meet one of their criterias, and you know what criterias I won’t meet? Well, I won’t meet for disability because, as somebody who is under-diagnosed which means I have diagnoses but none of them match the level of disability. So, in many ways they’re just kind of like a list of terms on a page that don’t really do anything.Ìý
Miri: We’ve had a lot of people that we’ve talked to who have had that same kind of problem.Ìý
River: Right. When you’re under-diagnosed-Â
Elianna: And then, of course, the enforced poverty of that. Once you’re on SSI, as a unmarried person, you only get $2,000 in total assets. That’s not money in the bank, that is total assets. Total assets and that’s a bar that was set in 1989. Then if you’re married, lucky you, you get $3,000 in total assets.Ìý
River: Oof. Russian and the gold right there. That’s maybe if you got cheap enough rent, three months rent. Maybe, if you’re lucky. It is unhinged the conditions that we have put disabled people into intentionally with no care. So, what I’m getting very aggressive and frustrated with is this idea that we have to sacrifice the long-term benefit because there’s a short-term problem. I need legislators to realize you can walk and chew gum at the same time. You can solve an immediate problem and to implement the long-term solution. But, if you don’t plan that long-term solution, then your immediate solution is not worth it; because you’re not solving the problem, you’re simply delaying the pain.Ìý
Miri: And then that’s how they-Â
River: And the pain is coming.Ìý
Miri: Oh, yeah. That’s how they lose the next election. Then how everything slides to the other side again.Ìý
Elianna: Then of course we’re talking about emergencies here, but when you try to do the thing that you’re told is the medical wisdom, which is get ahead of something before it becomes a serious pressing problem and then you have no idea what that costs. A couple years ago, when I was still on my mom’s insurance, I had this growth on my waterline that was rubbing up against my eye. I was about to start doing job interviews for a harder labor job, where it would be a problem for me to have a problem with my eye. It’s broadly a bad thing to have a problem with your eye, but if you need to be looking at stuff and being in intrepid places; you need your eyeballs. So, I went in to the place they told me to go to. I didn’t go under. I didn’t schedule a follow-up appointment. It was in and out within a couple of hours. The guy snipped off the little growth on my eye. He cauterized it. He sent off the little snip to biopsy to make sure it’s not cancer. The bill I got in the mail was for thousands of dollars.Ìý
River: Oh, yeah.Ìý
Elianna: And it’s like, “Oh, where did that come from?! I got the itemized list. Why is this thousands of dollars?”.
River: Right. I had a baby two months premature. There is no option for you as a parent if your child is born premature. There is a pseudo control authority that you have. But, you really are just having to do what the medical staff say you’re going to do. One, because that is your child and you want them to live. You can’t be sitting here being like, “I’m sorry, but I don’t want you to run this battery of tests or do this treatment because we can’t afford it.”. At that point they’re gonna be like, “Well, we’re gonna do it.”, and it becomes a whole darker conversation for families. So, you agree, and then you just shove aside in your head what those costs are gonna be and those costs are not cheap. Hardly no parent, I’m sure, is sitting here going, “I wanna have my kid in the NICU.”. But, on top of that, right now we have these cuts to the NICUs in rural areas, because it’s not profitable enough to have the safety of preemie babies in rural areas and that’s bullshit. It is. It’s not being cut, because this is the best care that can be provided It’s being cut because it’s cheaper to deny people that care. So, what a universal health plan does is it stabilizes it and allows that funding, again, to be based on need. I keep coming back to that, because that is not what we have. It’s what we’ve been sold, as the insurance model, that we’ll all pitch in and we can all pull out when we need. But, we know that’s not true. If your care is at all pricey, everyone tells you you’re gonna get denied the first time. Jokes about “Death Panels” from the Republicans years ago, we don’t have “Death Panels”, we have “Death AI”. It’s gonna run your code and it’s gonna deny it. Something like 80-90% of the time, if I remember correctly, that it will on the first round deny something. When a review is requested by a doctor, time and again, what we see, at least anecdotally, is that the people who are reviewing it aren’t the specialist needed. They’re a doctor, not the right doctor to review it.Ìý
Elianna: Or, even if that; we also know that there’s people with high school diplomas who are running the codes at the insurance companies and basically practicing medicine without a license, doing things for patients without seeing them. There’s plenty of doctors who post the clips online of them on the phone with the insurance company going, “Why are you denying this medication?”. I saw one recently where the doctor was extremely frustrated, because the insurance denied a specific medication for a patient and then said they should have the generic. But, the generic does not exist in this country yet. It will be approved down couple years from now. But, right now the medication they wanted the patient to use is not available in the country.Ìý
River: ¸é¾±²µ³ó³Ù.Ìý
Miri: And there was just that John Oliver piece about generics being under-regulated and often the active ingredient can be the same, but all the stuff surrounding it could be something you’re allergic to. If the difference is $600 a month for the medication that you can take safely or $60 a month for the medication that’s a risk every day; that’s not a choice. Most people don’t have $600 that they can throw around. on… And, Usually, if they do, they have insurance that’ll actually cover it. The insurance kicks down everything to the poorest people.Ìý
River: Time and time again, that’s what we see, and it forces all of the cuts that we’re seeing; plus the cuts from the big old beautiful bill. See, I’m learning! I think that should tell us something, right? The Republicans decided to pass a bill that would deprive people of food, of healthcare, and they decided to refer to it as “beautiful”. Is that what you guys think? ‘Cause I don’t. That’s not what I think of when I think of “beautiful”. I think of family, I think of connection, I think of friends. I think of people thriving, not people starving and dying from neglect. I think that speaks volumes.Ìý
Elianna: Well, I think for them, it’s kind of like the lingering eugenicist ideas of certain ideas of beauty being associated with not being poor, not being disabled, not being sick. So, it’s-
Miri: Not being a minority…Â
River: Yep. It’s a purity thing. Purifying out the people that they don’t want. Cruelty is the point. And I think that’s one of the benefits and differences with universal healthcare. It just immediately is that isn’t the point. It’s not profit. It’s not politics. It’s literally healthcare. It’s literally ensuring that people can take an ambulance when they need it to a hospital that they don’t have to go four or five hours for. This is something where we’re seeing these closures. If we get the universal health plan, we can start looking at rolling back some of that. Because, we’ll be able to plan for what is needed and maybe be able to restore some of those places. I can’t make those promises, but that’s the goal; is to look based on need. So, I think, when it comes to things like ambulances; yes, that is the plan, is to make sure that when you call 911 because you’re afraid you’re having a heart attack or a stroke. You can get that ambulance and you’re not worried about the bill. When it comes to things like paying for EMS, doctors, technicians, the way that, this would be dealt with– and Colin feel free to jump in if I’m getting something of this off– is that it would stabilize payments based on what the public employee benefits plan has. That’s the base likely to be used at this point. The benefit for that for doctors, for EMS workers, for nurses is; it’s not I’m gonna get paid $10 by Medicare. I’ll get paid 25 by United, and I might get 27 by Aetna. But, then also you have, with these variety of fees, you have to fill up all of this different paperwork. Your prior authorization might then get rescinded after the procedure has been done and then you don’t get any of that money. So, all of this “shenaniganry”, for lack of a better way of putting it is all of this that happened; we get a chance with a universal plan to cut through a lot of that insurance back and forth to make it a process that is simple and straightforward, where everyone understands, “if I do X, then Y.”. “If I do this, then that.”. That’s where the payments come from, it can be planned, it can be consistent, and can be stable. Instead of this constant hunt for money, following up with the insurance, “how many times have you called?”, “how many times have you checked your authorization?”, “how many times have you gone through the appeal process?”, “have you submitted the re-appeal?”. If you are in the medical field, you know the staff that you have to have just to fight the insurance companies to pay what they said they were going to pay and not even any extras. We’re not talking bells and whistles here. We’re talking about freaking basics. So, with a universal plan, what you get is, “Oh, here’s the procedure. Great. Here’s the payment. Next.”. Instead of this extensive back and forth that drains money and time, care, and literal life from a healthcare system.Ìý
Miri: Thank youÂ
River: Let me know if you have additional follow up on that!
Collin: I have one thing to clarify, River, which is that you mentioned the “PEBB Benefits”. You sort of threw it in talking about compensating providers. When we talk about the PEBB benefits, that’s like the “Public Employee Benefit Board”. That’s the current healthcare benefits that our governor, our elected officials, employees of the State of Oregon, have. That’s their health insurance. So, that’s more or less the tier of coverage that will be extended to every single person in the State of Oregon. So, a easy thing I like to say is; have as good quality of healthcare as our elected officials is the least that Oregonians deserve.
Miri: Wouldn’t that be nice?
Collin: Wouldn’t that be nice? Doesn’t that make a ton of sense for everybody? But, the thing that I think you conflated as it’s easy to do, ’cause it’s very confusing, is I don’t think that the compensation for those providers, I don’t think we can say that that is currently being pinned to the future provider reimbursement in 2032 when this is happening. I don’t think we can say that that’s gonna be pinned to the current rate of reimbursement for those PEBB, Public Employee Benefit Board, state employee insurance benefits. But, that same, whatever it is, and I can’t remember off the top of my head, the framework for that statewide planful, mindful, consistent reimbursement rate that will be basically the same rate around the state for every patient, right? So, any CAT scan in La Grande versus Medford versus Portland should be compensated the same way. So, that provider, that hospital would be paid by the state plan at that same rate. There is some discussion and caveats in decision-making that would change those rates based on very urban versus very rural places. But, my understanding is it wouldn’t be a huge discrepancy; Ontario versus The Coast. It wouldn’t be super dramatic. But, within the delineation of urban to rural, there could be some compensation differences, but I don’t know what those are and I don’t think anyone does at this time.Ìý
Elianna: Thank you for the clarification. Okay. It’s like with our nursing, EMT, and gerontology programs here 51ÁÔÆæÈë¿Ú. I’m sure our future health employees will be very appreciative to hear about these sort of details.
River: Yeah, and thank you all. To all of our health workers out there for their interest in this and for the work that they do. Because, part of my goal to get this through. Part of why I’m interested in this is, because I do view this as a way to provide some rescue support; some much needed rescue support for our healthcare workers so that we can fund staffing based on what they need. Not what’s gonna make the company the most money. The private equity firm that just bought the hospital system the most money that they can get out of it. Instead we can go to unions and have serious conversations about how to staff this appropriately, so that maybe healthcare workers could work like normal shifts and have days off and breaks and not be working insane amounts of hours that they shouldn’t be. I don’t know. Crazy idea. Maybe that’s just my wish in there. But, I think that’s part of what this is. It’s a real chance to honor our promises that we have made over the years to healthcare workers and undo the harm that’s been done and have their back.Ìý
Disabled Healthcare Providers
Elianna: This sounds like a lead into one of the other questions that we have. There’s a discussion that we have in disability spaces about the ability for disabled people to become providers. Because, higher education, broadly, has this glorification of suffering where it’s, “Oh, yes! You’re gonna suffer! You’re gonna live off cup noodle! You’re gonna go sleepless! You’re gonna destroy your body and mind trying to get this education!”. So, for disabled people where life can be broadly more difficult and then with the infamous rigorousness of medical school; it makes it so much more difficult for disabled people to become providers when these disabled people understand what it’s like to be disabled extremely well. For this definition of disability, I’m also including people with chronic pain and chronic illnesses or multiple situations going on with them. With this “Healthcare For All” plan; that maybe there would be an increased capacity for disabled people to become practitioners, like in the long-term goal, or do we know anything like that?
River: So, I was pre-medical, when I got into PSU. I had a 4.0 and I had the volunteer hours. I had all the things. If you ever looked at what they demand of pre-med students, I had all of that. Then my mom’s dementia became unmanageable back in Arizona, and just moving her up here collapsed my health. I got denied a wheelchair and then I got locked out of education entirely. So, I wasn’t even able to complete my bachelor’s degree. So, I just watched the dream of becoming a doctor, that could understand what it was like to have a chronic illness, just turn to dust and shatter. So, I understand that need very deeply and I would love to say that this immediately solves that problem, but it does not. This is another fight. This is unfortunately a different fight. I think this is a stepping plan to, because if we can start aiming a system that provides for doctors to be able to rest, then we have a chance at starting to be able to chip away at the absolutely insane idea that it is reasonable for things like; 180 hours in two weeks, or something, for people to work. Some of the numbers and shifts that I remember talking about. The outcry that happened when, I think, it was either Med Students or Residency had their maximum put at only 80 hours a week. There was this huge, “Oh, my God! Whatever are they gonna do with only 80 hours in a week? How are they ever gonna learn?”. And, I’m like, you’re just driving people through a crucible. You’re not teaching them the care. You’re stripping them of the capacity to understand and care by doing this. I don’t mean all doctors don’t have that capacity, but I mean it’s a lot harder when you have pushed and broken yourself to understand when you get to the other side. It can make it a lot harder to understand people who can’t get through that, because there’s a survivor bias. “I made it through, so if I did, you could.” This idea that if you just push harder and that disconnects doctors from their patients. Not intentionally. They’re still there to help. They’re still doing their best, but it does. If we can start by making it so that they’re not taking on two or three different roles in a hospital, nurses aren’t pushed into positions where they’re managing too many patients, so that we can bring that workload down. We can have that conversation about having more care and bringing more people in. I think it’s a step in the direction, but it’s not the focus of this. But, it is definitely something that us, in the Accessibility Alliance as part of Health Care For All Oregon, are going to be taking away from this conversation. How can we make sure to be implementing this? Because the work doesn’t stop as soon as we win. The work continues until everybody is in till everybody has what they need. I hope that answers that.Ìý
Collin: I’m gonna bounce off and I have more of a response. So, River’s part of our Accessibility Alliance, which is one of our that’s specifically focused on disabled rights, disability justice. River, you were mentioning earlier that you and some other leaders in that statewide caucus are working on the- can you say the name of the document you’re working on? What is that?Â
River: Right. So, the Accessibility Alliance is working to partner with the Health Care Providers caucus. I wanna say what it’s called- “Develop a Patient and Provider Bill of Rights”, that works together to build up the rights and include as part of the universal plan rights for patients and providers. Things that they can look and say, “This is what we meant from the start. This is what we wanted to ensure would happen with this.” So, including things in there like expanding access for disabled providers can be one of the things that we can put in there as an intention. It wouldn’t necessarily be part of the initial implementation, but it allows us by building it into something like that to lay the groundwork to do that as part of the next work.
Collin: ¸é¾±²µ³ó³Ù.Ìý
River: I hope that answers that. ³Û±ð²¹³ó.Ìý
Collin: Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, just for listeners, Accessibility Alliance and the groups that River mentioned; they’re part of our network of volunteers with Health Care For All Oregon, the nonprofit focused on this issue. So, if you wanna get involved and help create that document, which will eventually be sent towards our legislators and play a role in sort of our our statewide strategy over the next couple years. Please join us as a volunteer at . I wanted to talk about a little more, to answer your question, Elianna, about potentially some disabled providers and being able to access, or provide care to patients, or more of like a peer- it’s not quite the same thing as like behavioral health, a peer network, but it’s an important possibility. The only thing that we can say for sure is what’s in the draft plan and the draft plan from the Universal Health Plan Governance Board is available from the documentation from some of their previous meetings. So, that board’s website is . If you go to that site, you can scroll to the bottom and see their current and past meetings, and on the, I think, October 16th, one of those dates; if you open up that, there’s a little plus sign on the webpage. You open it up and you can see all the documentation, including a draft plan. So, that draft plan is going to be transformed by December 1st to the official recommendation, the official plan sent to our legislators. But, at this time, we can see the draft plan from October. Just while we were chatting, did a search for providers to see if there was a specific mention of disabled providers. I don’t think that that phrase exists in the draft plan. I know that it’s been brought up. But, frankly, I’ve been listening to quite a few of their monthly meetings and it hasn’t featured prominently. But, I do believe it was mentioned at least once or twice over the last two years. There’s a few paragraphs on this, on the draft plan, that maybe are relevant to this question I’m seeing it on page 73 and 62. The one on page 62 says– I’ll just read this paragraph, it’s in the middle of the page– “further work needs to be done to determine if providers will be paid more, less, or the same under a universal health plan. Multiple factors will determine that, including how the standardized fee schedule is structured and each provider’s payer mix. The effects of changes can be mitigated with a variety of strategies, including phasing in new rates and methodologies and adjustments to protect rural safety net.”, and then this is the last wording, “or other vulnerable providers.”. So, I think that that’s a very soft goal statement, goal paragraph. But, they know that some providers, especially, those categories and people who are disabled, who are also providers are part of that, quote, “vulnerable provider population”, they know that they can’t be ignored.Ìý
Miri: That’s a good thing to hear coming from a meeting like that.
Equipment & Right to Repair
River: One of the things I know that you were, talking about was the cuts through disability equipment services and issues with people with pre-existing conditions. The benefit to this is- insurance companies, again, pardon me if I sound like a broken record, but they cut based on profit, right? When you have a large pool coming in like this; what we’re gonna be able to do when it comes to Meds is advocate for those lower costs as a larger group as the whole state of Oregon, which is bigger as a economy than some countries. So, we will have some lift in what we’re doing here to be able to do that. To be able to advocate for a stabilization of repair prices and such. Definitely one of the things that I hope to build into the “” is the , which is utterly essential for disabled people to have for their own equipment. The right and ability to be able to take components that are identical to a bicycle. Just because it’s attached to a wheelchair doesn’t mean the wheel is that different. Take it to a bike repair shop and get that work done and not have to worry about that stripping coverage. So, this is stuff we look to build into the “Patient Bill of Rights” side of things that we wanna develop.Ìý
Miri: There’s so much medical and disability assistant equipment that is proprietary; where you can’t have anyone else work on it without voiding the warranty or voiding your insurance coverage for it. Which can be either incredibly expensive and also just take forever if you are, say, a wheelchair user like you said and you have to send your wheelchair in somewhere, and it could be weeks then before you get it back. Then what are you gonna do in the meanwhile?Â
River: Right. For able-bodied users, I want you to imagine your legs just disappearing for three weeks. Nobody giving you anything, maybe some crutches, and that’s if it’s somebody that’s… we’re just talking like paraplegic there. We’re not talking quadriplegic. We’re not somebody who needs a full mechanized chair. So, just the way that strips people of basic humanity is utterly insane to me, the basic ability to just be able to move in your environment. I think that is again where having a collective builds strength. Because a collective unit can then bargain with the equipment manufacturers to require that their warranties allow for local repair and these are things that the legislature can demand. There’s no reason that they can’t include this sort of thing in there. So, if this is something that is driving you, even just casually interests you; call your legislature, send them an email, drop them a message, and let them know that this is part of what you wanna see reflected in there, that warranties not be able to be voided, that the people not have their equipment sent out and that there be replacement and loaner devices if something needs a long-term major repair for whatever reason.Ìý
Miri: Yeah. Getting medical equipment repaired can be more expensive and more difficult and take more time than getting your car fixed. Insurance is gonna fight you even harder. Potentially, if the insurance decides they don’t want to fully cover it and you are on that SSI limited asset pool; “oops!” there goes everything that you are allowed to save in order just to repair the thing that you need to keep living.Ìý
River: Right. Right now you face denials like I did with my health insurance that denied me my wheelchair because and I quote, “I only needed it outside the home.”! This was back before DoorDash. This is back before I could have all the online appointments I have now. Back before Zoom University. This was back when I had to go in person to everything. Again, having that larger structure allows for better bargaining, like you see with large unions. It kind of works that same way with a universal health plan. It gives that collective power. The way that we have control over that power, especially right now, is to talk to our legislatures. Be annoying. Be loud. They work for you. Make ’em work. They’re making that ban plan now, so make ’em work and get it for us.Ìý
Miri: Yeah. Especially on a day like today.Ìý
Elianna: The one thing I would say, about Right To Repair is that it also needs a clause that things must be repairable. Because, then what usually happens in my experience is then the company goes, “Oh, okay, we’re just gonna make it to where you need to break this thing if you wanna repair it.”, Or they just make it completely incapable for anyone to mess with it. There’s the power wheel, booster wheels, you can add to a manual wheelchair to give them a little more boost. But, then it’s like you control it through an app. So, if you wanted to make this thing actually usable, especially in the long term and have it be remote control, you’d need to rehardwire it, and then find a way to clip it to your-
Miri: You’d have to literally hack it.Ìý
Elianna: Then it’s like you need to physically take it off to shift what mode it’s in for it to go; broadly faster or broadly more slow, depending on where you are. Or, even the horror stories of people who get implants and then the company goes under. People just have this surgically implanted thing to help them hear or do some other kind of thing for their functioning; now that company is gone and they’d need surgery to remove whatever this thing is, if that’s even viable and safe.
Miri: Or, it’ll still be in their body. If it’s controlled by an app but the company’s gone out and you get a new phone, then that app isn’t on the App Store anymore, you’re like, “Well, really hope I can just get my insulin numbers based on vibes today.”.Ìý
River: Right.
Elianna: Like with the whole “cyberpunk sci-fi dystopian movies”, and everything like that; when are they gonna cover what is actually happening right now? When are they gonna “Handmaid’s Tale”?Â
River: Right?
Collin: That sci-fi makes me think of “Only In American Hollywood” could think of; “65” with Adam Driver where the cost of healthcare in this alien society is so expensive that he has to fly his spaceship into primordial Earth, 65 million years into the past to cover the cost of his daughter’s healthcare.
Miri: You know, the, the goth classic, “Repo! Genetic Opera”, where you got a new liver? Hope you can keep paying for it forever!.
River: Right!? Otherwise we’ll send a repo guy to come collect it. I’m a hardcore lover of dystopian fiction. Don’t get me wrong. I was reading it a little young for what I think you’re supposed to be reading it for. I was definitely in elementary school! So, I love the-Â
Miri: But, I think the fiction; I like it-
River: I like it fiction! Yeah, the fiction. That was not supposed to be set out as like a plan. This is like a fundamental misunderstanding, guys. Machiavellian [sic] wrote “The Prince” as satire and then a bunch of guys were like, ” Ah, yes. This is how we rule!”, and-
Miri: “The Torment Nexus” from the, uh, the famous piece “Don’t Build the Torment Nexus”?Â
River: Exactly!
Miri: ³Û±ð²¹³ó.Ìý
Elianna: Exactly! “Welcome to the dystopian fiction, Ms. Turner. You’re in one!”Â
Taxes & Accountability
Miri: I think a lot of the concerns that people have about single-payer healthcare is the tax stuff. People don’t like paying taxes. That it is gonna turn into like One Who Walked Away from Omelas of like, “Okay, who do we let suffer, officially, so that everyone else can thrive?”. Which is already happening, but since it’s done behind closed doors; on the 30th floor of a 29-floor building, as opposed to in front of us with our votes going into it, people just don’t see it as much as they would if it was right in front of us.
Collin: So, yeah. There already is rationing care right now in this status quo. I’ve had physicians who are connected to our movement describe it as like; “rationing lives”, right? ‘Cause people are choosing to avoid care, because it’s too expensive. Then they get to the emergency room and it’s already a dire situation and they lose their lives at a higher rate than in other countries. Who to blame for this disaster is “everybody and nobody.”. It’s like our legislators, it’s the Oregon Health Authority, it’s these insurance companies that have their CEOs in Michigan, or far flung places, like far from Oregon-
Miri: Connecticut.
Collin: Connecticut, right. So, these organizations who are not in Oregon are killing people in Oregon based on their behavior and their decisions and there’s nobody for us, Oregonians, to blame. The single-payer system would create a new nonprofit corporation that would be based in Salem functioning as– this is a little sidebar, but , S-A-I-F, which is the worker’s compensation program for Oregon employees– in a similar way, it’s providing a service specifically for those employees for the state of Oregon. This would be this public corporation acting as the insurance company for everybody in the state. Anyway, that’s, like, how it could function. But, there’d be a building with a door, with humans inside it that Oregonians who are currently furious with their healthcare with literally nobody to blame besides everyone and no one; there could be a central point both to applaud successes, but also to go to call on the phone to complain about a dysfunctional system. I think people would say, “Oh, the OHA, Oregon Health Authority, exists currently.”. But, they are not wholly responsible for this entire disaster. Neither would this new statewide insurance plan for everybody in Oregon, but it’d be a different way to approach this problem because it’d be the singular system that is covering every resident. So, there’s an opportunity to effect change at this place that actually exists as opposed to the amorphous blame blob, “what do we do? Who’s at fault right now?”
Miri: “Everybody and nobody.”
River: Exactly. What I would say to the tax question is I understand people don’t like paying taxes, so I guess my question is, how much do you love paying for your health insurance premiums? How much do you really love paying your co-pays? How much do you love paying for your medications out of pocket for services that were then supposedly covered and then not covered? Are those better? ‘Cause, here is your choice right now. You can either continue this really expensive system; where you can go broke at any moment, no matter how much money you have. There are very few people who have enough money that they can survive a catastrophic illness with all of the incumbent costs. If you get multiple myeloma and you need expensive treatment where the exploratory medication is in the hundreds of thousands of dollars per dose, do you make enough to survive that? Because, most people in the United States don’t. So, you’re pouring all of this money in, you’re not able to get this care. What we’re offering instead is a way to cut that down so that you’re not paying those premiums. So that you’re not relying on your employer for your health insurance, so that you’re able to continue to have medication and stabilize it, so that if you change jobs you don’t suddenly have to be like, your new insurance company’s going, “Yes, well. We don’t cover that particular medication. We’re gonna do this medication,” and have your whole thing upended just because you took a better opportunity for your family. So, if you don’t like taxes, I get it. I don’t think anyone likes taxes, but you already are being taxed and it’s going to corporations. Why don’t you go for something where it’s gonna go to you and have people accountable?Â
Miri: It’s similar to what you were mentioning earlier about shifting the compensation for procedures and such from being billed afterwards to just being like this is a standard thing, it gets paid out. Where paying your tax is that you’re paying for it ahead of time. Versus, when you have to go in and pay tens of or hundreds of thousands of dollars for something after it happens.
River: Right, and the amount of the cost is not something that’s gonna be borne by most people. The way the tax is structured is most people in Oregon would see a negligible increase in their-Â
Collin: Like 30% perhaps. Hard to say, but 30% is the number that I’ve heard. So, if 70% of Oregonians will spend less in this transition to universal healthcare and maybe 30% would be spending more. But, crazy, they wouldn’t be surrounded by sick people, could be great.Ìý
River: Right. So, 70% of people paying less, whereas just 30% of people would be paying just a bit more. Ultimately, everyone gets access to the same coverage at that point. You’re not paying into something you’re not getting back on. You’re paying into something that you get from. Instead of this feeling of your taxes just disappearing, or your insurance money just disappearing. That’s how I always feel; I feel like I’m paying this huge amount out of my check when I’ve been working. It’s half my check, because I’m always trying to get the top plan to protect myself as a disabled person. I’m making a pittance, otherwise, just so that I can have that, because that’s all gone. Without that having to be in there, that’s more money that you can use on your day-to-day; where you don’t have to save for a medical emergency. You can save for– I don’t know, here’s a crazy idea– maybe a vacation.Ìý
Collin: ³Û±ð²¹³ó.Ìý
Oregon Leading the Way
Miri: Health Care For All Oregon has stated that Oregon is closer to accomplishing single payer healthcare than any other state. Do you think success in Oregon can lead the way for higher GDP states with similar movements like New York, Washington, or California, where that entrenched money might put up more resistance?Â
Collin: The answer is, “absolutely”. Also, the entrenched money is also taxpayers in those states. So, those states, like Washington and California, will be able to get more money from taxing their billionaires. I think we’ve got one or two. I don’t know-Â
Miri: We got like the “Nike guy” and that’s it.Ìý
Collin: Right. Exactly. But-Â
Elianna: Phil Knight’s is gonna bankroll everything. We’ve got Biketown, we’ve got Laika, we’ve got…Â
Collin: Whatever, I’m down. Do what you want. Yeah, sign me up. Also people that are working at the national level; we are the most likely. We are the only state with a constitutional amendment guaranteeing healthcare as a fundamental right. We’re the only state with this universal health plan governance for delivering their plan on December 1st. We’re the only state that is this close at this time of crisis, and there’s this quote, “Don’t let a good crisis go to waste.”. It is a disaster right now. Our system is totally broken, and Oregon does have the best chance of being this first domino to fall. A lot of people will say, “Oh, it could never be done as a state. It has to happen at the national level.”. That’s not what happened in Canada. In Canada, Saskatchewan was the first province to make this transition, and within 10 years of Saskatchewan transitioning to their Medicare For All– Saskatchewanian residents– the rest of the country had their Medicare For All system. So, we’re thanking– as an organization– thanking Ron Wyden for signing on recently to the Medicare For All legislation, and also our Representative Janelle Bynum. She is another Oregon Democrat who signed onto that federal legislation. So, all of our Democratic representatives have signed on to the national Medicare for All legislation. District 2, Cliff Bentz, is the lone Republican, and he has not signed onto it, and he has stated that he opposes it. But, I think there’s a chance that Cliff could change his mind. So, if that happens, as an organization, Health Care For All Oregon would thank him in the same way we thanked the Democratic representatives for making this commitment for Medicare for All. All that’s to say we think Medicare for All would be great, and we do not see it as a possibility based on the last 200 years of our federal government not implementing Medicare for All. So, we advocate for this work to happen at a state level first and Oregon has the best chance of being that state. It all comes down to this kind of education and enough Oregonians understanding the differences and choosing to talk to their coworkers, their friends, their neighbors, and hopefully make this correct decision in 24 months from now. Two years from today will potentially be election day 2028, when hopefully, Oregonians will be voting on this issue.Ìý
River: Yep. So, push your legislator, and once that gets out of the legislature, sign. If you need to sign petitions, get out there, sign petitions, help us get signatures on those petitions. Then when it goes to the ballot, vote, “yes”. Those are our next steps. I trust you guys to get it done. You guys can do this. I think it says a lot about the moment we’re in that Janelle Bynum has signed on. Even people who are more moderate are seeing how desperately something needs to change.
Collin: Universal healthcare is moderate. Universal healthcare is normal. The inability to discuss it is super abnormal and bizarre and terrible. So, yeah. Universal healthcare is normalcy, and people that don’t want it are wrong.Ìý
Miri: Yeah, it’s that weird-Â
River: And becoming increasingly rare, you know? Even in rural areas, there’s call for change. Because, they’re seeing so many of their clinics shut and bought up by private equity to serve absolutely nobody.
Miri: And, the fact that a private equity firm can earn money by closing a business or closing a a pharmacy, closing a clinic, closing any sort of coverage like that. That them taking that loss can earn them more money, as always, in the short term than actually trying to run that and make money from it.Ìý
River: ´¡²ú²õ´Ç±ô³Ü³Ù±ð±ô²â.Ìý
Elianna: We were just talking about like politics in rural Oregon and it’s everywhere around the globe. Even conservatives, who are extremely conservative and say some pretty interesting things around the globe, they’re still for universal healthcare. It’s only here that it’s kind of like a conservative stance to be more “pro private”? Like I don’t want the government telling me about my healthcare. But, then we do see in rural Oregon that we are losing care out; whether it’s schools, whether it’s transit… I know there’s lots of people around Oregon who need to transit into Portland to get certain medical care. Because, this is where all the medical infrastructure is, and then the clinics that are out there are getting shut down. So, it would be nice to see greater capacity for movement and desire for universal healthcare in the more sparsely populated parts of Oregon.
River: Yeah. I think there are bridges that can be built. There’s… What is it? Rural-
Collin: Rural Organizing Project?Â
River: Yeah, that’s what it is. They’re an excellent group to connect with if you’re in a rural area to support this work. As well as, with Healthcare For All Oregon as well. I always believe in partnering with groups that have already done work in the area and they’re a great example of that. We know because you just have to listen to some rural people real quick to find out they’re tired of all of these cuts. All of their services being cut. Another hospital closure, another place being bought out. This is the case where we have heard these complaints from the rural communities that their pharmacies are going missing, hospital coverage is going missing, ambulance coverage is going missing, and they are rightfully feeling neglected. This is an opportunity to correct that injustice. That’s what it is. They shouldn’t have to rely on private equity to save them, because they won’t. Every time they step in, what they do is they strip the money out and then they leave a desiccated husk, if that.Ìý
Collin: Right. One thing, in our social media landscape, is comments saying, “Oh, hey. I don’t want the government involved.” But, the government is involved and they shall, no matter what, unless there’s no future where the government, it has, quote, “no involvement in your healthcare”. But, it’s just so disjointed and dysfunctional. I think Obamacare saved a lot of lives, but it’s a mandate to have insurance. So, it’s a mandate for you to give your money to these private corporations. Instead of a mandate on the healthcare system to actually provide care to residents, and that’s the problem, or one of the problems. So, we’re seeing what happens when government is less involved in the actual delivery of care and more involved in who gets the dollars and that has led us to the most expensive system in the world that has everyone, I know and love, pretty frustrated.
Miri: You would hope that if we have the most expensive, we would at least have the best. But, do we even rank top 50?Â
Collin: Well, I think we are in the top 50. I don’t have that exact number. We are, we have great-Â
River: We’re at the bottom for “developed countries”.Ìý
Collin: We are at the bottom for lifespan and cost. So, we’re spending the most, and we’re living the shortest amount of time. When you actually get to your place where you’re receiving care, we are rated one of the highest. If you can actually make it through these many challenges, these many burdens, the impossibility of arriving to get the care that you need; once you pass through that, then we have great care. But, as far as the equity some of the main metrics of measuring the strength or the functionality of healthcare systems are; maternal mortality, infant mortality, and lifespan. Those three metrics for our peer nations, there’s 35-ish wealthy nations that all have universal healthcare. All of them are spending less money than us. All of them have higher performing metrics on those three indices. That I mentioned. Getting to the care you need is the hard part. But, once Americans get it by spending a bajillion dollars, we do have high-quality care.
Elianna: Yeah. Imagine if we got that same care, but now everyone’s not going broke.Ìý
River: ¸é¾±²µ³ó³Ù.Ìý
Collin: ±õ³¾²¹²µ¾±²Ô±ð.Ìý
River: That’s what the Universal Plan is. There was one question. I know you guys had kind of thought about asking earlier about; would we be able to provide veterinary care for service animals? I wanna use this as kind of an example of how this plan can benefit past what it covers. So, the answer to that is “no”; it is not currently built into the plan. If you’d like that to be part of the plan, please call your legislatures. You may have heard me mention this already. What it does do is it takes off those costs, those premiums, the money; if you’re a small business owner, instead of spending all of this money trying to get your employees health insurance, or leaving them without it. You can then offer a “vet plan”. You can have more money to pay for the groceries we are all struggling to get the Veterinary Insurance for the cute little fuzzball who went and got a kidney disease for no good reason. You can do that, because you’re not pouring all of your money into just keeping yourself and your family alive. So, is it built into that plan? It isn’t right now. Maybe at some point it can be. But, what it does do is it gives you that freedom. It gives you that opportunity for real freedom and real choice, rather than the illusion of choice and the illusion of freedom that different insurance companies offer. Because, they’re all running the same metrics when it comes to cutting off, off from care. They all run the same numbers that it’s cheaper to deny care than it is to cover it. This is a different way to do it, so you get that and keep your money, and you keep your choice, and you have more freedom to do the things you want
Elianna: ³Û±ð²¹³ó.Ìý
Small Businesses & Freedom
Elianna: Do y’all have any metrics on what money this would save for local businesses or smaller businesses? ‘Cause I know I brought up earlier; Ford can’t compete in the international car game the same way other cars can, because they have to put all this money towards their medical programs. So, for smaller companies, more local companies that are here in Oregon, how much money would they save if we had universal healthcare, so then they don’t have to take care of their employees? Would this help them, our local businesses, survive and thrive?
Collin: It definitely would be good for small businesses. There is information which, like I said, should be released on December 1st with the full proposal indicating that as a state, the Universal Health Plan Governance Board, has estimated and calculated that as a state, we could save $6 billion a year about with this potential new system. There’s a few, there’s lots of caveats and there’s a few other situations where that number gets smaller or lower. But, 6 billion is one of the numbers that they landed on. So, that’s as a state. As far as the nuances of when smaller businesses would have to pay, or what would their current payment would compare to this potential new universal healthcare system; one of the lines for when those payments begin for shifting to individuals, for an example. At the current proposal, individuals will start paying their personal healthcare premiums. So, a new tax replacing your insurance premium, but kicking in after 200% of the federal poverty level. We could do a whole other hour and a half podcast about how the federal poverty level is terrible. But, at the current decision factor of when Oregonians would start to pay into this new universal healthcare system is around 200% of the federal poverty level. So, for an individual, around $32,000 income for the year. That’s for an individual paying into this new system. Corporations are also factoring in heavily to this potential plan. So, premiums from individuals based on our income, those federal dollars, so those waivers that I mentioned for Medicare and Medicaid and the third part of the main three-legged stool, providing, getting the revenue to provide this insurance system is a tax on businesses. So, that was a long preamble to say currently, I think every business is different depending on your number of employees. Smaller businesses are spending a lot of energy trying to figure out what their health insurance should be, and then also jumping through their hoops to provide that insurance to their employees. So, there’s five revenue proposals that will be available on December 1st. So, five different options that our legislature needs to decide on before they– fingers crossed– turn this into a bill that we vote on. For businesses, the main line in the sand, or the main tier, of when those payments would begin is around $500,000 for global payroll for that whole business. So, if you’ve got a small business that has three employees, each making $100,000. Well, first of all, amazing. But, you would only have $300,000 of payroll for those employees. So, that business, the individuals, because they’re residents of Oregon, they would be covered under this statewide plan. But, that business would not start contributing to the new universal healthcare plan for the state of Oregon until the amount of payroll exceeds $500,000. So, let’s say that same business has six employees, each at $100,000. It’s now past that $500,000 payroll cap, and that is when the small business would begin to pay into this new universal healthcare system. All of that’s subject to change, but that’s the best answer.Ìý
Miri: Awesome. Cool.Ìý
River: That frees up companies to not have to focus on deciding the plans, coming up with the plan, managing the plan. You no longer have that middleman that you’re having to worry about. You can just be like, “Cool, we pay this one thing,” and then they handle it. Go see who you wanna see. I mean, do companies really like being the middleman for insurance? ‘Cause I’ve never met a business owner that really loves that part of the job. Did they open a bakery in order to be able to manage healthcare for people? So, yeah.Ìý
Miri: Sounds like some terrible Steam game. That would also come without a bunch of, like, “Surprise! Your premium’s going up this year!”, or “Oh, you filed one too many things last year that wouldn’t have been too many two years ago, but is now too many. So, we’re gonna double your rates!”. ‘Cause it would just be something that, anytime there would be an adjustment, it would be public knowledge well beforehand and probably voted on.
River: Yep. That’s it. That’s exactly it. It is about freedom in, I think, the truest sense of the word. Freedom to be able to choose who you see, freedom to be able to save your money for things that you care about, freedom to be able to run your business how you wanna run your business without having to sit there and deal with these complicated health insurance things to offer and to pay. This is a huge portion of a lot of benefits packages is that amount. If companies wanna still offer that, they can. The health insurance will still exist. They can still offer these as add-ons. It’s not like it’s just poofing. But it means that it doesn’t have to be a big part if a company doesn’t want it. Again, it’s freedom to, you know? It’s a freedom to be able to do these things.Ìý
Miri: ´¡²ú²õ´Ç±ô³Ü³Ù±ð±ô²â.Ìý
Upcoming Events & Getting Involved
Miri: Before we end up here; if there’s anything that you want our listeners to know about that we haven’t covered already, then now is the time to share that. We also put links to everything discussed below and if there’s additional information that you want our listeners to have; you can send that to us, and we will put it in the web article.Ìý
Collin: Okay. Thanks so much for having us, Miri and Elianna. It’s been a really winding conversation. We’re stoked to talk about this clearly for hours. This is the tip of the iceberg about what could happen in Oregon with our potential transition to universal healthcare. I’ve wanted to just tell listeners that there’s a couple events. There’s events happening all the time with Health Care For All Oregon and there’s lots of ways for volunteers to get involved. So, you can see our full list of events, including our chapter meetings around the state, different, committees, different caucuses, and other tabling; there’s lots of stuff at . There is a rally that we wanna tell people about on Sunday, November 14th, which is the Workers Rally for Universal Healthcare. Labor leaders within our nonprofit are reaching out to different unions. We’ve got sponsorship from quite a few of them attending this event, wearing their union colors, and showing that there’s solidarity amongst the unions for this idea of universal healthcare. So, that’s in downtown Portland at the World Trade Center. I think it might actually be on the east side. I forget. But, anyway, it’s at the World Trade Center, noon on November 14th. Then there’s another statewide mobilization event… Well, two more, actually. On December 1st and 2nd in Salem, we’ll be going to the Government Offices and having individual one-on-one meetings with our legislators. So, December 1st is when the plan will be delivered to them. We’re gonna have as many people as we can, as many Oregonians as we can, coming to their offices to have one-on-one conversations about not letting this amazing plan just sort of fumble and fizzle away. We wanna have this plan transition to be a bill that we can actually vote on and decide for ourselves if we want universal healthcare. So, that’s December 1st and 2nd in . Also, in Salem, on March 16th, there’s gonna be a , and so those are our biggest events that are upcoming over the next few months.Ìý
River: Yeah, and if you are interested on one of these things down in Salem, but you’re not sure; reach out and we’ll do what we can to facilitate. Get people with carpool or just trying to coordinate as best we can to get people there. So, we will do what we can but reach out. I would rather have you reach out and find things to get you connected with to be able to get you there, ’cause the more of us to show up, the better. If you’re someone who is one of the chronic illness besties, out there, that needs to stay at home; that’s okay too. We can absolutely accept support by you calling in, by sending an email; whatever is the method that works for you to communicate directly with your legislators. If you are somebody that is a member of the disability community or you are disability community adjacent please join the Accessibility Alliance. We also have a Queer Caucus, or the LGBTQ Caucus, as well as a healthcare providers and a mental healthcare providers caucuses as well. So, join, come in, chat. We absolutely want all of you engaged in this. If you’re not sure, if you’re hesitant, we want you to show up even more. We wanna hear. If you have doubts, you have questions, you have concerns, reach out because that’s how we’re gonna get these answers. That’s how we’re gonna alleviate your concerns. We want this because we want this for you just as much as we want it for our neighbors and everybody else. So, if you have concerns, don’t hesitate. Send a message and we’re happy to do what we can to address those concerns and to help you feel heard and understood and bring you in.
Miri: Well, thank you both so very much for both taking the time out of your day to come and talk to us. Also just for all the work that you and your organization is doing to better the lives of the people in this state, and then hopefully eventually in this whole country. So, it’s been absolutely fantastic talking to you guys.
Elianna: Thank you so much for coming on, and thank you so much for talking with us.
Outro
Kylo: Thank you for listening to Let’s Talk, 51ÁÔÆæÈë¿Ú’s broadcast about disability culture. Find more information and resources concerning this episode and others at pcc.edu/dca. This episode was produced by the Let’s Talk Podcast Collective as a collaborative effort between students, the Accessible Education and Disability Resources Department, and the PCC Multimedia Department. We air new episodes on our , our Spotify channel, , and .Ìý
Resources
- Website:
- Action Network: Sign a Petition